Thursday, September 26, 2013

Taylor White
Progymnasmata: Confirmation and Refutation
BP Oil Spill


Confirming that BP did all it needed to do to prevent the oil spill-
BP took all necessary steps to prevent the oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico. BP had blowout regulators on all of its rigs, yet in this case, the blowout regulator did not work properly and the oil rig exploded anyway. BP also put in concrete walls, made by Halliburton, to prevent the leakage of oil into the ocean. These walls were not stable and did leak and did not work properly. These two instances are not faults of BP. BP took all necessary regulations to prevent this spill and yet the poor construction of two products made by other companies resulted in this massive oil spill. There was no way to know that these two procedures were faulty because BP did not make these things. The oil spill would have been prevented if the products of other companies worked properly. BP took all necessary and normal operating procedures to prevent this spill and this could have happened to any company's oil rig if there preventative mechanisms were faulty. BP however did take responsibility  for the situation and has spent billions of dollars of there own money fixing the situation. BP attempted to fix the problem at the source of the spill but no engineers could go down to the base of the rig with the oil spilling out to stop it. BP is one of the top oil and gas companies when it comes to reducing there footprint on the environment. They have established a whole team and department of there company dedicated only to preventing their carbon footprint. BP's environmental goals are to recognize and reduce their impact on the environment. After the spill BP took ever necessary step to minimize the impact of the oil spill. BP sent fleets of boats out to minimize and dispose of the oil and to collect the oil and get it out of the ocean. BP immediately began the recovery process of the oil spill in order to reduce their environmental impact and should not be held responsible for the faulty mechanisms of other companies.

Refutation-
BP knew there oil rig blowout mechanism was faulty and did nothing to fix it. It is BP's responsibility to ensure the products that go onto their rigs function properly in order to ensure that something as catastrophic to the environment never happens. Reports show that there was a negative pressure test on the rig that showed a problem with the function of the rig. No action was taken, no professional on the subject was consulted. Especially troubling is the fact that two engineers were on the rig that could have fixed this problem! Yet no one consulted the visiting engineers and the blowout occurred. BP obviously did not test the effectiveness of the blowout regulator and the concrete wall that was supposed to stop the release of oil into the ocean. This points the blame to BP alone. BP did know there was something wrong with their rig and did not fully inspect and insure the effectiveness of their preventative regulators. BP oil rig operators did not stop the drilling of oil in order to check the problem, therefore BP should have set precautionary procedures that their employees should take in order to prevent this catastrophic event. BP also did not put into affect any procedure or way of shutting down the rig and its drilling if it exploded. There was nothing engineers could do to stop the leaking of the oil into the ocean but simply watch and wait until it stopped flowing. If BP would have enacted or put in some kind of mechanism to allow the stoppage of the spill. In this lies on of the biggest problems. There was no way to stop the leak. If there was some way that BP could have stopped the leak after it happened then there would not have been nearly the catastrophic effect on the environment. The fact that BP had to wait for the oil to stop flowing at such a high rate is the real problem with this issue.
Time ran out.



No comments:

Post a Comment