Thursday, September 26, 2013

Taylor White
Progymnasmata: Confirmation and Refutation
BP Oil Spill


Confirming that BP did all it needed to do to prevent the oil spill-
BP took all necessary steps to prevent the oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico. BP had blowout regulators on all of its rigs, yet in this case, the blowout regulator did not work properly and the oil rig exploded anyway. BP also put in concrete walls, made by Halliburton, to prevent the leakage of oil into the ocean. These walls were not stable and did leak and did not work properly. These two instances are not faults of BP. BP took all necessary regulations to prevent this spill and yet the poor construction of two products made by other companies resulted in this massive oil spill. There was no way to know that these two procedures were faulty because BP did not make these things. The oil spill would have been prevented if the products of other companies worked properly. BP took all necessary and normal operating procedures to prevent this spill and this could have happened to any company's oil rig if there preventative mechanisms were faulty. BP however did take responsibility  for the situation and has spent billions of dollars of there own money fixing the situation. BP attempted to fix the problem at the source of the spill but no engineers could go down to the base of the rig with the oil spilling out to stop it. BP is one of the top oil and gas companies when it comes to reducing there footprint on the environment. They have established a whole team and department of there company dedicated only to preventing their carbon footprint. BP's environmental goals are to recognize and reduce their impact on the environment. After the spill BP took ever necessary step to minimize the impact of the oil spill. BP sent fleets of boats out to minimize and dispose of the oil and to collect the oil and get it out of the ocean. BP immediately began the recovery process of the oil spill in order to reduce their environmental impact and should not be held responsible for the faulty mechanisms of other companies.

Refutation-
BP knew there oil rig blowout mechanism was faulty and did nothing to fix it. It is BP's responsibility to ensure the products that go onto their rigs function properly in order to ensure that something as catastrophic to the environment never happens. Reports show that there was a negative pressure test on the rig that showed a problem with the function of the rig. No action was taken, no professional on the subject was consulted. Especially troubling is the fact that two engineers were on the rig that could have fixed this problem! Yet no one consulted the visiting engineers and the blowout occurred. BP obviously did not test the effectiveness of the blowout regulator and the concrete wall that was supposed to stop the release of oil into the ocean. This points the blame to BP alone. BP did know there was something wrong with their rig and did not fully inspect and insure the effectiveness of their preventative regulators. BP oil rig operators did not stop the drilling of oil in order to check the problem, therefore BP should have set precautionary procedures that their employees should take in order to prevent this catastrophic event. BP also did not put into affect any procedure or way of shutting down the rig and its drilling if it exploded. There was nothing engineers could do to stop the leaking of the oil into the ocean but simply watch and wait until it stopped flowing. If BP would have enacted or put in some kind of mechanism to allow the stoppage of the spill. In this lies on of the biggest problems. There was no way to stop the leak. If there was some way that BP could have stopped the leak after it happened then there would not have been nearly the catastrophic effect on the environment. The fact that BP had to wait for the oil to stop flowing at such a high rate is the real problem with this issue.
Time ran out.



Thursday, September 19, 2013

Taylor White
Progymnasmata: Common-place
"Those who take advantage of our country's welfare system are leaches to society."

 Disclaimer- I am not attacking our country's welfare system, simply those who TAKE ADVANTAGE of the system. The welfare system is a necessary and good function for society.

Exposition- A leach; sucking, stealing the nutrients out of its host. Nutrients that the host worked hard to provide for himself. The leach does no work of it's own, stealing the product of another being is its way of life. The leach contributes nothing to the animal kingdom; it is not an autotroph that contributes to the benefit of the animal kingdom, nor a heterotroph that uses nutrients to do work. The leach lives, breeds, and dies based upon the work of its host. The leach is not capable of surviving on its own; therefore, it is an ever bearing nuisance to its host. 

Contrast- The crime of stealing others money when you yourself are capable of providing for oneself is only possible through the hard work of others. Millions, like myself and my peers, put themselves through college. Not only attending class and studying, but working a job, volunteering, and getting involved in the University are major time and effort commitments. Putting oneself through the difficult task of college, oft through lack of sleep, in order to be a productive member of society is something that those taking advantage of the welfare system will never have to do. Instead they sleep late, eat snacks provided by the hard work of others, and watch cartoons on there 42' flat screen TV that, guess what, is provided by the hard work of you and me. Meanwhile, citizens of this country get up early, stay up late for work in order to make a name for themselves, to be self reliant, productive members of society.

Comparison- Robbing a bank, beating up an old lady for her purse, stealing change from the charity bin at McDonalds, a bully holding a nerd upside down and shaking the money out of his pocket, taking advantage of our welfare system. What do these all have in common? Stealing money. What would happen if someone robbed the local bank? They would be arrested and put in jail! Or if someone mugged the little old lady who swallowed the fly and took her purse, what would happen? They would be put in jail! So why would the stealing the money of the hard working, blue collar American not be punished? All of these examples are analogous.

Intention- Those who take advantage of our countries welfare system intentionally stay home and do no work because they are lazy. Even those people who do actually live under a rock know that our country is exporting the work load of our companies to other countries. Our country needs able bodied men and women who could fill the positions that are being filled by the foreign countries who compete with us on a global scale! Yes, there are people who do need welfare for medical reasons and also because they genuinely cannot find jobs, but I am talking about those people that live their whole lives on welfare. Those who are physically able to find jobs and contribute to society should willfully do so; they know that they can work and simply come up with excuses so they can be hand fed the spoils of those who worked for it and they themselves did nothing.

Rejection of pity- Those who choose circumvent there duty to society to be an able bodied member should be punished to the fullest extent of the law. Stealing is universally accepted as wrong and in this instant should be treated as no other thing than the illegal act of taking what does not belong to you. These people are a detriment to society because we are funneling money to them with no return. Another issue raised is that these people are not working, and therefore not paying income tax which hurts our government and puts an even larger burden on the middle class to support these people. It would be financially better for our already economically declining nation to put these people to work, which would in turn provide more money for society and the government. We should give no pity to those who can work and choose not to.

Possibility- The immediate result of this change would be a financial upturn for our country and society. More money comes into the government means better running of the government and better amenities that the government can provide for all of society. Another benefit would be creating a better quality of life for those who get off the couch and stop living off of the government and healthcare. These people would make a name for themselves and become more self-reliant. And the quality of living would be better than that if he had not started working. Solving this leach problem would be a benefit to both those who take advantage of the system and society as a whole.

Thursday, September 12, 2013

Taylor White
Gun Control

Stasis:Conjecture
Does it exist? Is it true?
  • Proposition 1:Guns cause crimes
  • Proposition 2:Guns don't cause crimes.
Where did it come from?
  • Proposition 1: The violence that follows the use of guns is the problem. Violence is the problem
  • Proposition 2: Violence is not only caused by guns.
What caused it?
  • Proposition 1: Gun violence is caused by the gun, people could not kill people without the action of the gun firing a projectile. 
  • Proposition 2:Gun violence is caused by society and the increasingly desensitized people who play violent video games and "shoot 'em up" movies. 
Can it be changed?
  • Proposition 1: Yes, it can be changed by laws.
  • Proposition 2: No, guns cannot be outlawed; they are a staple of American society.
Definition
What kind of thing or event is it?
  • Proposition 1: Gun control is the act of regulating the output of guns into society, thus causing less violence. 
  • Proposition 2: Gun control is not applicable because it is the right of the citizen to own a gun and defend himself. This right is thus provided by the Second Amendment. 
To what larger class of things does it belong?
  • Proposition 1:  Gun control is directly related to the safety of the American citizen. The loss of some privacy is necessary to help the common good(this has been seen in airports and the monitoring of our cell phones. 
  • Proposition 2: Gun control belongs to the basic rights established by our Founding Fathers and the Second Amendment to the Constitution. 
What are its parts? How are they related?
  • Proposition 1:  The regulation of guns being only distributed to certain people after an extensive background check is necessary to public safety. Also, initiate a waiting period to curb gun violence, and to regulate the types of guns being sold.
  • Proposition 2: There should be no background checks or waiting period to receive the basic right of having a gun. Regulating the types of guns sets a precedent for outlawing all guns. Rating guns by their deadliness and effectiveness to kill another human being will eventually lead to the fact that all guns are effective killing machines and they should all be outlawed.
Quality
Is it a good thing or bad thing?(or comparatively is it better or worse than something else)
  • Proposition 1:Gun control is a good thing to protect the safety of everyone. The police and government should be the only ones who possess guns because they can protect us from those who illegally possess firearms. It is conceptually better for no one to have guns which would eliminate gun violence. 
  •  Proposition 2: Having guns is a basic right that is necessary to have in order to protect oneself from anyone trying to harm you or your family. One needs also to be able to protect oneself from the government. Guns give the people power over the government so they can fight back against a government who  may want to control its people. When diplomacy and rhetoric does not prevail, man turns to violence. Criminals would inevitably get guns and the law abiding citizens would not have guns to protect themselves from the criminals. 
Is it right or wrong?
  • Proposition 1:  Violence is caused by guns; therefore, we should outlaw the guns, or at least control the output of guns, being so readily available.The right thing to do is to protect others by outlawing guns.
  • Proposition 2: We should not outlaw the use of guns because the gun provides the citizen with the ability to protect himself from those who would want to harm him. Violence in any form is not right, but no one can outlaw all things that cause violence. 
Is it honorable or base?
Proposition 1:  It is honorable to outlaw guns because it would create a safer environment for not only us, but also for our children to live in.
  • Proposition 2: It is honorable for the citizen to be able to defend not only himself, but also his family and not have to rely on the government for yet another thing. This provides independence for the citizen. 
Policy
Should some action be taken?
  • Proposition 1:Yes, guns cause violence and less/no guns would provide a safer environment for our nation. 
  • Proposition 2: No, guns give the power over the government and gives the people the power to protect themselves from those trying to harm them. 
What actions are possible/desirable?
  • Proposition 1: Guns should be outlawed to stop violence.The quality of people that receives guns should be higher so that those who are unstable should not receive them. There should be a waiting period to stop those who have a hot head from using the guns. The kinds of guns should be regulated in order to stop the effectiveness of killing large amounts of people/ 
  • Proposition 2: No guns should be outlawed because it sets a precedent to outlaw other guns and eventually outlaw all guns. 
How will the proposed change affect the current state of affairs?
  • Proposition 1:  Outlawing guns would provide a safer environment for the whole nation.
  • Proposition 2:Outlawing guns would provide criminals with power over the common man who abides by the rules to not have guns, thus increasing violence. 
How does the proposed change compare to other proposals?
  • Proposition 1:  The proposition to outlaw all guns would probably not pass due to the current mindset of citizens. However the regulation of guns is a viable option that will cause less violence. 
  • Proposition 2: Guns should not be outlawed because the people would lose there power. Guns provide the people with the ability to defend themselves from criminals and protect there loved ones.

Thursday, September 5, 2013

Bob Dylan
"All the money you made
Will never buy back your soul."


     Bob Dylan undoubtedly was one of the most influential musicians of his time. Dylan did exactly what musicians strive to do:move people. This movement is to make people feel emotion, yet Dylan took his talents to a whole new realm. Dylan moved people not only emotionally, but moved them in such a way as to illicit political movement. 

     In context, Dylan was speaking about the weapons manufacturers who were profiting exponentially from the mass killing of humans. It seemed as if the more profit the weapons manufacturers made was directly parallel to the increased effectiveness of killing men. This concept can be used readily in the modern world. The more effective weapons manufacturers are at their jobs, producing weapons that kill people, the more profit they make. One specific concept that is ever present in the modern age is the use of atomic bombs and chemical weapons. Dylan proposes the concept that the weapons manufacturers themselves are responsible for the lives of those lost from their products. How does one cope knowing that this bomb they are making could destroy millions of lives?
     Dylan suggests that the money is the coping mechanism to justify the making of such a destructive force. The killing of so many humans by war was the primary conflict Dylan was singing about. Dylan questioned the profiting of the weapons manufacturers who would never have to see the horrible effects of their products; Dylan wonders why those who make these weapons are not held responsible for what they do. This concept is once again readily discussed in our modern times. The issue of nuclear warfare is the lives it would destroy, the long term affects of using a nuclear warhead on the environment and livable areas surrounding, and also of humanity itself. an underlying meaning that could be derived from Dylan's song that holds true to today is how could those who produce these weapons cope with the fact that they could possibly end up destroying humanity. The money made will do nothing to recount for the lives lost and the lives changed. 

     If those weapons manufacturers and those who control the bulk of the arms discontinued valuing human life, then what would stop the killing? In his song, Dylan subtly addresses the value of human life. In this time of change, in which the value of each human's life being the same and that everyone is of value, to think of destroying human life, and in such mass numbers, is a concept that is so absurd to Dylan that he moves people to ending the war and ending the destruction of something so valuable as a human life. Dylan suggests that if the leaders of our nations, those who make and control the weapons, ever lose the sentiment, the value, of human life, this is when those like Dylan have failed and we as a society have failed. 


     Nuclear weapons however are not yet banned, but the concept of banning nuclear weapons is a highly contested topic. Hollowpoint rounds are however banned in some states and on the battlefield due to the fact that they are too destructive to the human body, as compared to a normal bullet(as if a bullet isn't already ha). The belief that the human spirit is something of unlimited value and that weapons manufacturers should not be allowed to profit at such a substantial rate for destroying the human body and spirit is congruent to what Dylan is singing about. 


     The leader of the modern world, the most influential man on the planet, the man who leads the greatest nation in the world, the president of the United States himself backs Dylan's stance about the value of the human life and believes that nuclear weapons should be illegal. Obama's "Road to Zero" is a plan proposed that would eliminate all use of nuclear weapons in the world. 

Dylan's song move people toward political action and to value the human life above profit.